Article

New towns, old ideas: What can we learn from the history of new towns?

As the new Labour Government eyes its 1.5 million housebuilding target the obvious question is where will these homes go?

As the new Labour Government eyes its 1.5 million housebuilding target the obvious question is where will these homes go? As part of our wider series looking at how the UK will build more and better homes, our New Towns miniseries will explore the past, present and potential of New Towns to meet the UK’s housing needs.  

The Government rose to power on a promise to ‘get Britain building’ and one of its most headline-grabbing policies was to create the next generation of New Towns. 

Often-maligned as ‘ugly,’ ‘soulless’ and ‘boring’ New Towns were an answer to a housing crisis of a different kind in post-WWII UK. Following extensive damage to housing stock due to the protracted bombing of cities during the war (and later seen as a solution to urban overcrowding) the New Towns Act (NTA) saw 32 settlements completed between 1946 - 1973 across the UK.

New Towns were constructed in three waves, the first of which included Stevenage, Hemel Hempstead and Basildon. Today these places, along with locales outside the Southeast like Runcorn and Telford, have a mixed reputation but does their history offer any lessons for Labour?

In theory: Housing utopia 

New Towns were dramatically different from the Concentric Ring Model (CRM) that everyone will remember from their school geography lessons and that defined the unplanned urban growth associated with the industrial revolution. 

The central business district, transitional zone, working class zone, residential zone and commuter zone ‘rings’ that defined CRM were to go, replaced by unitised residential areas (with an emphasis on social home provision) organised around amenities like schools and hospitals, with segregated industrial zones to protect from noise and pollution.  

The ideology behind New Towns focused strongly on designed-led solutions and revolutionary features such as dedicated public transport provision to allow movement throughout the town, innovations to encourage walkability like covered underpasses and pedestrianised town centres, as well as the UK’s first covered shopping centres. Green spaces were also key following the Garden City experiment of the 1900s; low-density housing allowed for grass verges and front gardens, formal and informal parks often separated residential neighbourhoods, and a green belt for agricultural and leisure use was envisaged for each town. But did the theory deliver in practice?

In practice: The good the bad and the ugly 

Today over three million people live in New Towns, and they have come a long way since the post-war era. After a rocky start with many original residents suffering from the ‘New Town blues’, attributed to a lack of community ties and social atmosphere, now some perform well in national rankings albeit not for the reasons intended by their designers. 

In 2024 the Sunday Times ranked Milton Keynes fifth in its UK ‘Best places to live’ index thanks to the town’s green spaces, strong infrastructure and car-free walkways. For these reasons as well as affordable housing Milton Keynes and other New Towns such as Hemel Hempstead prove popular with young families and first-time buyers. 

However, their affordability, rail connectivity (each has its own station), and proximity to London has given many New Towns commuter town status, running contrary to their intended purpose as self-contained economic and social units.

Likewise, the rise of the personal vehicle has seen New Towns characterised by high levels of car dependency making many of their well-intentioned design features redundant or worse. 

New towns have good transit connectivity and extensive active travel networks (Milton Keynes is home to the highest percentage of cycle lanes on roads in the UK at 16%), but the planning ideology behind these decisions has not always translated into reality. The low-density housing favoured by planners created extensive roads and other infrastructure which per head is expensive to maintain, creates longer journey times and means that public transit is costlier to fund resulting in high car-dependency.

Modern planning decisions have not always helped matters. Large, out-of-town developments such as retail parks and leisure facilities are common in New Towns and car use is encouraged, for example Basildon Sporting Village lies only 1.2km from the Basildon’s central train station as the crow flies but has over 450 car parking spaces which are at capacity most evenings and weekends. 

Developments such as these undermine the original New Towns vision further by contributing to town centre decline and increased car dependency with poor public transport alternatives. Today many New Town centres are rundown with little footfall while their underpasses and walkways are disused, unappealing and associated with antisocial behaviour and crime while residents use their cars to access retail parks. 

Lessons for Labour

Modern planning has advanced a great deal since the post-war era and the last decade in particular has seen a paradigm shift in favour of active and sustainable transit over personal vehicle use. If Labour is to deliver on both its 1.5 million housebuilding target and reduce carbon emissions, the Government will need to combine the good intentions of the original new town planners with some up-to-date planning orthodoxy.

In the original New Towns, transport planning was a secondary affair, retroactively designed after housing neighbourhoods, in short the same issues faced by organically grown settlements. The Government now has a chance to learn the lessons of the original New Towns and build a generation of connected, sustainable and healthy communities. 

 

Off

Subscribe to our newsletter, The Edit

We are Steer

Yes, you are in the right place. After 40 years, we have changed our name from Steer Davies Gleave to mark our growing international footprint and our expanding portfolio into sectors beyond transport.

Explore our new website to learn more about Steer: who we are, how we work and what our future holds.

Related insights

  • 17 Dec 2024
    Article

    Steer Leads Multi-Consultancy Team on Culture Mile BID’s New Vision for a Connected, Greener Neighbourhood

    By Steer

    The strategy aims to transform the City of London’s Culture Mile into a more connected, accessible, and vibrant cultural neighbourhood.

    Read more

  • 12 Dec 2024
    Article

    Steer analysis offers data-driven, transit-oriented view of green and grey belt potential

    Oliver Russell
    Associate

    Steer has launched an online story map showcasing the potential for sustainable, well-connected green and grey belt development.

    Read more

  • 18 Jul 2024
    Article

    The King’s Speech: Our key takeaways on planning, transport and the energy transition

    By Steer

    King Charles sets out the new Labour Government’s legislative agenda which intends to ‘take the brakes off Britain’.

    Read more

  • 02 May 2024
    Article

    What can the Local Area Energy Plans learn from two decades of Local Transport Planning

    Serbjeet Kohli
    Director

    Do local authorities hold the key to Net Zero in the UK?

    Read more

  • 18 Apr 2024
    Article

    Promoting Sustainability in the Colombian maritime industry

    By Steer

    We spoke to Silvana Giaimo, Director of Corporate Affairs at the Cartagena Port Group, to learn how the company is tackling social,

    Read more

  • 03 Jul 2023
    Article

    The Investability of EV Charging Infrastructure

    Profile image
    Matthew Clark
    Associate Director

    Governments around the World have targeted a hefty expansion in the number of publicly available EV charge-points.

    Read more

  • 15 Jun 2023
    Article

    La Rolita: transforming public transportation in Bogota with gender equity

    By Steer

    Carolina Martínez, CEO of La Rolita, gives an insight into this transformative project offering leadership roles to women.

    Read more

  • 24 Aug 2022
    Article

    Carbon is not a local transport problem

    Simon Statham
    Director

    Simon Statham looks into what needs to be done in order to think differently about transport carbon emissions.

    Read more

  • 31 May 2022
    Article

    Crossrail – it wasn’t quick or easy, but it is wonderful

    Adrian Cole
    Consulting Director
    Victoria Rees
    Associate Director

    As Crossrail completes its first week of passenger service, it's a good opportunity to reflect on the work that led to this milestone.

    Read more

  • 20 May 2021
    Article

    Planning Reforms — a chance to get things right

    In the recent Queen’s Speech, the Government reconfirmed its desire to speed up the development process.

    Read more

  • 21 Apr 2021
    Article

    Is flexibility the answer?

    Undoubtedly, the COVID-19 pandemic has imposed a sudden stop to our daily routine and reshaped our mobility needs and priorities.

    Read more

  • 22 Jan 2021
    Article

    TfL Streetspace judicial review: lessons for transport planners and engineers

    The High Court upheld a judicial review brought by the London taxi trade against TfL's Streetspace Plan.

    Read more